Royal Bank of Canada Annual Shareholders Meeting
Apr 06, 2018 PM UTC
查看原文
RY.TO - Royal Bank of Canada
Royal Bank of Canada Annual Shareholders Meeting
Apr 06, 2018 / 01:30PM GMT
==============================
Corporate Participants
==============================
* David I. McKay
Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director
* Karen E. McCarthy
Royal Bank of Canada - VP, Associate General Counsel & Secretary
* Kathleen P. Taylor
Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board
* Neil McLaughlin
Royal Bank of Canada - Group Head of Personal & Commercial Banking
==============================
Conference Call Participants
==============================
* Daniel Thouin
* Jason Ho
* Rachel Megitt
* Shekher Puri
* Willie Gagnon
* Joseph Chirico
==============================
Presentation
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [1]
------------------------------
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. (foreign language) Welcome to our Annual Meeting of Common Shareholders. I'm Kathleen Taylor, and I have the privilege of being the Chair of the Board of the Royal Bank of Canada. I'm pleased that so many of you could join us here in the room today, many more are with us on the webcast.
As notice of the meeting has been duly given and a quorum is present, I call the meeting to order. You may address this meeting in English or in French. If you'd like a translation headset, please raise your hand, and an attendant will assist you. English is on channel 2 and French on channel 10.
After my introductory remarks, Dave McKay, our President and Chief Executive Officer, will make a presentation, followed by the regular items of business, including the election of directors and the appointment of the auditor. Shareholders will also be asked to approve a nonbinding advisory resolution on our approach to executive compensation. We will then deal with any other business, including questions from shareholders. After the meeting, RBC representatives will also be available at the information desk located in the lobby to answer any additional questions you may have.
Please note the caution posted on the screens. At this meeting, we may make forward-looking statements, which involve certain assumptions, have inherent risks and uncertainties. Actual results could differ from these statements.
As always, we welcome questions and comments from shareholders. Some guidelines are set out in the agenda that you received this morning. Please keep your comments brief. In fairness to other shareholders, we ask that you limit your remarks to just a few minutes and speak only once to each matter that comes before the meeting.
At the appropriate time, if you'd like to ask a question, please proceed to a microphone. When you are called upon, please start by giving your name and tell us whether you are a shareholder or a proxyholder. Shareholders who are watching the annual meeting via the Internet may also submit questions through our website.
Before we begin, I'd like to take a moment to introduce the others who are with me on the podium. From your right to left, we have Rod Bolger, our Chief Financial Officer; Dave McKay, President and Chief Executive Officer; and Karen McCarthy, Vice President and Associate General Counsel and Secretary. I will act as Chair of the meeting, and Karen will be our secretary. Pina Pacifico and Joe Chirico, officers of our transfer agent, Computershare Trust Company of Canada, will be our scrutineers. Also present are members of our board and senior management team.
At RBC, we believe good governance is good business. We regard governance as a dynamic and ongoing process that is foundational to RBC's success. Central to our role as your board is our responsibility to ensure that RBC has the right strategy, risk management and talent to deliver long-term value for shareholders. We provide guidance to management as it builds a digitally enabled relationship bank and focuses on markets and segments where RBC is positioned to succeed. We advise management on strategic plans, challenge their assumptions and assist in identifying and building pathways to sustainable growth within the bank's risk appetite.
Equally essential to RBC's success is the leadership of a talented executive team backed by dedicated employees who execute our strategy with excellence. In that regard, we were pleased to announce at the end of last year that Graeme Hepworth will assume the role of Chief Risk Officer on Monday, succeeding Mark Hughes. Graeme's deep expertise in credit and market risk and exposure to all of our key businesses, along with his global perspective, will benefit RBC and its shareholders.
I also want to thank Mark Hughes for his significant contribution to the bank's success over his 37-year career at the bank. Mark's strong understanding of RBC's businesses, along with his deep insights into the ever-evolving risk and regulatory environment, made him an unexceptional group Risk -- group Chief Risk Officer. Mark, on behalf of the board, your colleagues and all of the shareholders, thank you so much for the contribution and dedication you have shown to RBC.
Once again, in 2017, RBC was recognized for its high standards, winning Best Overall Governance at the Excellence in Governance Awards in Toronto and Best Overall Corporate Governance - International at the Corporate Governance Awards in New York. But continuous improvement has always been part of our commitment. We continue to set ambitious objectives in our pursuit of governance excellence, and we'll always seek to engage with our key stakeholders in creating new and innovative approaches to strong stewardship that align with RBC's strategic objectives, create long-term value for our shareholders and reflect the values we have as a bank.
And now it's time to hear from Dave McKay about the bank's performance and its future outlook. Dave, over to you.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [2]
------------------------------
Well, thank you, Katie. And good morning, everyone, and welcome to our 149th Annual Shareholder Meeting.
A couple of months ago, I traveled to Switzerland to join international leaders at the World Economic Forum. And from an economic point of view, the mood among the Davos crowd was more bullish than I'd seen before, and companies and communities around the world have also felt that economic benefit. In our 2 core markets, Canada and the U.S., unemployment hit or is at a 40-year low. And meanwhile, Europe is well into its recovery, and Asia is providing more synchronized growth than we've seen for decades.
The message from the Swiss mountains was clear, that overall, global operating environment is better now than it has been for years. As I left Davos, thinking of everything I'd heard, one unifying theme was at the front of my mind: I believe that the next decade will be defined as a new era of mobility of goods, of people and of ideas. In the 90 days since and certainly, as we've seen volatility return to the markets, I've heard this theme again and again, in conversations with clients, onstage at the IBM Think event and during a visit to students at Conestoga College, a polytechnic in Cambridge, Ontario.
I know our future success as a company, as a society, including here in Canada, will depend on how we prepare for and engage with this new age. Of course, many of us are already living our lives via one of these smartphones. And it's fundamentally reshaping our business and communities, and this will only accelerate. It'll not just be about devices in our pockets. Wearables, the Internet of Things, driverless trucks and cars, all of these are already into their second or third generations and will be fully or more fully integrated into everyday society over the coming decade. It will affect our infrastructure and transportation requirements. It will change our conversations about data. It will create a need for different skills, and it will continue to alter how all businesses serve their clients.
So today, I wanted to take this opportunity to talk about how we are preparing RBC and our communities for the 2020s in a digitally driven decade of mobility and to show how our purpose will guide every step that we take on this journey together. Because as RBC moves into the next decade, how we achieve our success will be as important as what we achieve.
And certainly -- and RBC certainly continues to achieve significant success. Our financial performance in the last year demonstrates our focus on building a sustainable growth trajectory with lower volatility and delivering a premium return on equity even as we grow outside of our home market. It also illustrates the strength of our diversified business model and our disciplined approach to managing costs and allocating capital and investing in future growth. But most clearly, it demonstrates the power of our purpose to unify all of our colleagues under a common goal so that every RBCer can feel the impact that they are having on clients in our communities.
In 2017, we reported record earnings of $11.5 billion and achieved all of our medium-term objectives, delivering a return on equity of 17%. We returned a record $8.2 billion of capital in dividends and share buybacks, reflecting our commitment to you, our shareholders, while at the same time continuing to execute on our growth strategies. And we carried this strong performance into 2018, posting first quarter earnings of $3 billion and, again, delivering a premium return on equity of 17.4%. So overall, we have outperformed our global peer group, delivering compound annual total shareholder returns of 18% over 3 years and 16% over 5 years.
Since our last AGM, we have made outstanding progress against our strategic goals, serving high-growth client segments in our core markets in Canada, in the United States and select global financial centers.
Beginning outside our home market, the United States. The U.S. is absolutely fundamental to sustaining our growth. Central to the strategy of both our Capital Markets and Wealth Management businesses, our goal is to be the preferred partner to corporate, commercial, institutional and high-net worth clients in the United States. We're already making excellent progress as we execute against that strategy. 5 years ago, the U.S. accounted for 18% of our total revenue. Today, that figure is 23%. RBC Capital Markets now derives over half its global earnings from the United States, and we're adding coverage in research, lending, advising, trading and investment banking.
I recently returned from visiting my Capital Markets colleagues in New York City, and you could really feel the energy that's buzzing through the business. Some of the signature deals that we worked on in the last few months include supporting Sempra Energy and its recent acquisition of Energy Future Holdings, Meredith Corporation's acquisition of Time Inc. and Blackstone and CVC's acquisition of PaySafe. This U.S. growth has been reflected in Capital Markets earnings overall, which in Q1 reached a record $748 million, up 13% over the previous year.
Our U.S. Wealth Management business is also going from strength to strength, with double-digit revenue growth in 2017 and again in Q1, and continues to benefit from the hugely successful integration of City National Bank. We've already realized significant synergies between City National and our existing broker-dealer business, and we see further opportunities to build on this. We continue to invest further in this momentum, adding more client-facing advisers in recent months as we grow our commercial banking coverage and expand our presence in large U.S. cities, including in Washington and New York.
We believe the recent U.S. tax reform will be positive for the U.S. economy and our business. And while uncertainty over NAFTA remains a concern for our customers on both sides of the border, so far, clients and markets have been broadly working through this uncertainty. We're in close dialogue with governments and our customers, and we remain hopeful of a good outcome for both sides.
Outside of the U.S., we continue to improve our competitive position in select financial centers. And many of our businesses in the U.K. and Europe are enjoying positive momentum as part of our focused international strategy targeting institutional and high-net worth clients. For example, our Investor & Treasury Services business posted record results in Q1, reflecting the benefits of investments we've made into client technology and the favorable global market backdrop. Client acquisitions and favorable markets also benefited our Wealth Management business, whose earnings in Q1 were up 39%, with Global Asset Management adding more than $40 billion in assets under management over the last 24 months, outgrowing the market.
In Canada, where we hold the #1 or 2 position in all key banking categories, we have had an exceptionally strong start to the year. We're continuing to deepen our relationships with our clients and explore new ways to add value. We see opportunities for further growth, specifically in commercial banking, investments, deposits and in credit cards.
Owning a home is an important part of the Canadian dream, and we want to help ensure that Canadians own homes that they can afford. After tighter conditions last year, we're seeing more balanced pricing in the housing market. Policy changes in Ontario and other provinces have contributed to a welcome shift in market psychology towards more caution. And we remain very comfortable with the characteristics and credit performance of our mortgage portfolio.
We're focused on bringing the best of the whole of RBC to our clients. We're developing new partnerships to give our customers greater value. Our priority is on always providing an exceptional experience, and our feedback confirms that we're hitting the mark. In 2017, we were very proud to be awarded Highest in Customer Satisfaction Among the Big Five Retail Banks in Canada by J.D. Power for the second year in a row. We're also ranked highest among our peers in their first-ever award for our financial advice.
The trust and loyalty of our clients -- the trust and loyalty our clients place in us is core to our purpose, but we never take this trust for granted, particularly when it comes to our stewardship of our clients' personal data. We are diligent at maintaining the highest possible privacy and security standards and being transparent and explicit around customer consent. And we increased our investment in areas to make sure that we continue to stay ahead of this evolving issue.
Our digital and innovation strategies are fundamental to fostering this trust and loyalty, particularly as we adapt to a changing -- or to changing client preferences. We recently passed a significant milestone in our journey to becoming a digitally enabled relationship bank. Mobile is now our #1 digital channel with 3.4 million active users, up 19% over the last year. And 85% of our financial transactions are performed in self-serve channels. And our clients are increasingly finding added value as they engage with us on their mobile phones, resulting in RBC ranking first in J.D. Power's Mobile App Satisfaction survey in 2017.
One great example from our Insurance business is Path. This app was built by a team of co-op students. It provides our travel insurance clients with alerts, policy information and advice on the nearest medical facilities in case of an emergency. More than 500 customers are already downloading it every month.
And our Canadian banking clients -- and for our Canadian banking clients, we recently launched NOMI Insights and NOMI Find & Save. Created in our innovation lab in Orlando, Florida, NOMI provides our 3.5 million, 4 million mobile clients with increased insights to help them with their day-to-day needs while they're on the go. This makes the RBC mobile app the most used money management platform in the country. And our clients who use NOMI's predictive technology are twice as likely to save than those using traditional self-serve products. This was just one of 22 new mobile app capabilities that we released to retail customers in the last year.
We are investing considerably in artificial intelligence for the benefit of all our clients. And today, we have over 200 data scientists working across RBC. This investment is helping us redefine our trading businesses, it is helping us improve our fraud detection rates, and it's driving new products like NOMI. And through our machine learning institute, Borealis AI, we are ensuring that RBC is at the cutting edge of applied research, which will lead to many more innovative products in the future.
But it's also about much more than that. This is a critical time for Canada as it reinforces its position as one of the leading global centers for artificial intelligence. We were the first company in Canada to launch an AI research and development facility. Borealis AI provides academics in Edmonton, Montréal, Toronto and in Waterloo with the crucial freedom to focus on curiosity-driven fundamental research, including finding solutions to some of the greatest environmental challenges that our planet faces. Our focus on both applied and fundamental research shows how we are truly living our purpose when it comes to our investment in artificial intelligence. It is the most transformative technology of our age, driving new skill requirements and is a catalyst for a new era of mobility.
The accelerating power of AI and machine learning is the most significant force of change that is impacting the relationship between the financial service industry and our customers. For example, in the past, we would be our customers' first stop. I remember this well from my own time in the branch, besides family or closest friends, we were among the first to know about significant life events, business changes or new financial needs. This has enabled us to build a deep connection with our clients. And today, our customers are increasingly broadcasting their intentions more publicly via social media and in their search patterns. This means that our newer competitors, the big players in search, in social media, in e-commerce, can quickly pick up on these data cues. As these technology players realize their digital dividend, there is a risk that our visibility with clients will diminish in the networked economies or ecosystems of the future.
We hold some crucial assets in our home market: our deep relationship with our clients, our own secure data advantage and, most importantly, a trusted brand. So as we look at our strategy in the 2020s and beyond, we recognize that to continue to succeed, we need to reimagine the role that we play in our clients' lives. This means moving from satisfying a part of the clients' experience to orchestrating a broader experience for them. We have identified a number of ecosystems, those digital spaces where our clients live and work, where we believe we can play an integral role in their future.
In the last year, we've already taken some bold steps on this journey, building new, stand-alone customer propositions and creating some extremely exciting and mutually valuable partnerships. In the business-to-business space, we have collaborated with Wave to integrate invoicing, accounting into our financial insights -- and financial insights into our business banking platform. This unique service makes it easier for small business owners to manage their finances, which means they can spend less time being a CFO and more time being the CEO.
And we recently released Drive, a digital glove box that empowers car owners. It centralizes your car needs, from recall notices to valuations, and gives you the ability to book service appointments directly from your phone. Drive is just one of many apps that we're working on to add value for our clients and to take away the friction and hassle of dealing with multiple service providers. We'll be talking more about our ecosystem strategy in the coming months, and we're very excited about what the future holds. We believe our ideas, our partnerships and our new ventures will be game-changing. Together with our brand strength, we truly hold a unique position in our home market.
But for all our investments in AI and a mobile-driven future, let me be very clear: while RBC may be enabled by technology, client-to-colleague relationships will always remain at the center of who we really are. We are very much a human bank, a relationship bank powered by technology. And wherever we operate in the world, the continued success of this human bank will be driven by inspiring colleagues like Ava, [Morel] and Meryl. It's almost unbelievable to think that only 40 years ago, it was illegal for a woman to be present on a trading floor. Ava, an RBC investment adviser, decided to change all that. Thanks to her persistent lobbying, the law in Canada was changed. Ava continued to advise our clients until her retirement from RBC just last year. I'm delighted that Ava is here today and would like to take this opportunity to recognize her for her huge contribution to society. Ava, thank you.
Ava, you moved the dial. But there's so much more we need to do to create greater social and career mobility. Today, a year before we celebrate RBC's 150th anniversary, I would like to reinforce once again our commitment to inclusion, a fundamental part of our purpose. The last few months have shown that in our society, too many people are struggling to be treated equally and with dignity. I see this responsibility of every colleague to hold each other accountable for being inclusive and seeking out different opinions and perspectives. This is the only way to develop our workforce, the future-fit skills and capabilities we need.
This is why diversity and inclusion runs through our new leadership model, which is driving a bolder, more nimble culture and encouraging entrepreneurial spirit across the whole of RBC. And as always, RBCers are continuing to rise to the challenge, driving new and innovative ideas every day. And the results speak for themself, with more than 94% of our colleagues telling us that they are proud to be a part of RBC. I see that pride in the eyes of my colleagues every day. And so I'd like to also take this opportunity to thank every single RBCer for everything they have achieved. Thank you for your commitment and dedication to our clients.
Ladies and gentlemen, 5 years ago, my predecessor outlined RBC's commitment to make every effort to provide employment opportunities in Canada. This will not change and remains explicit in our Supplier Code of Conduct. RBC remains committed to supporting a strong Canadian workforce. Contributing to Canada's prosperity is at the heart of our purpose as a company. The operating environment in Canada is in many ways very positive, and this remains a great country to run and grow a business. Whatever the outcomes of the NAFTA negotiations, Canada must do more to ensure its competitive edge. This is not just about taxes but addressing how we get our goods and resources to market by road, rail or pipeline in a sustainable way. The Canada of tomorrow will have to be more flexible, more open and move faster than ever before.
And in particular, we have to help prepare the next generation for a future economy that will depend on a mobile-skilled workforce. In a recent landmark report, we identified the quiet crisis faced by Canada's youth. While the headline unemployment numbers in our country are strong, nearly 1/4 of college and university graduates are in jobs that they're overqualified for. And almost 900,000 young Canadians are not in any education, employment or training program. Many young Canadians are wondering whether they'll be ready for the future of work. They're right to be asking the question. As our report found, in the next decade, at least 50% of Canadian jobs will require significant change to the skills needed to do them, and more than 25% of Canadian jobs will be heavily disrupted by technology. Disruption, yes, but it does not need to be a threat.
I described earlier how RBC is, at its core, a human bank powered by technology. This is defining how we are moving into the next decade. With nearly 2.5 million jobs expected to be added to the Canadian economy over the next 4 years, this humanity can also be our nation's competitive advantage. These new jobs will see a demand for foundational skills, such as social perceptiveness and complex problem-solving. In other words, critical thinking, creativity and collaboration.
Just as we are reimagining our future at RBC and creating compelling experiences for clients, we are also helping Canadian youth reimagine their futures so that they can own the 2020s and beyond. RBC Future Launch is our answer, a 10-year $500 million commitment to help young people prepare for and navigate a new world of work that we believe will fundamentally reshape Canada in many of the communities within which we operate. We believe that we need to change the conversation. As a country, we have to rethink how we educate, train, hire and reshape our nation's workforce, to encourage mobility and to foster resilience.
Through Future Launch, we're calling on educators, businesses and governments to come together to help redesign and refund our education systems, training programs and labor market initiatives. And we're calling for bold steps, for employers to hire for core skills, not for credentials; for a country to take new approach to financing, reskilling and through funding lifelong learning opportunities; and all for postsecondary institutions -- and for all postsecondary institutions to agree to the goal of creating meaningful work-integrated learning placements for all undergrad students. We need to get this right because when our young people succeed, so too does Canada.
Our country is on the move, and with RBC Future Launch, we have set out our plan for making a difference for our youth. This is one of the most important things that we have ever done and is truly our purpose in action, a future in which RBC will have an even greater role in helping our clients thrive and our communities prosper. And I know that, with our future leaders managing then building the Canada of tomorrow, we will be in good hands.
So thank you. And with that, I'll hand the meeting back over to Katie.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [3]
------------------------------
Thank you, Dave, for that excellent, informative and passionate presentation.
At this time, I'd like to introduce Bill McFarland, Samuel May and Alaina Tennison, the representatives of PricewaterhouseCoopers, our auditor, for the 2017 fiscal year. Copies of the auditor's report and the financial statements have been mailed to shareholders and are also available at the information desk. Shareholders will now have an opportunity to ask questions on the financial statements. If your question relates to a matter other than the financial statements, please wait until the time provided for shareholder questions, following the formal legal business of the meeting. If you have a question on the 2017 financial statements, please proceed to the nearest microphone.
I'm not seeing any questions on the financial statements. As there are none, we'll proceed with the business of the meeting. You've received the notice of meeting and proxy circular, which specify the matters to be considered at this meeting. I'll now ask Karen to review the voting procedures. Karen?
------------------------------
Karen E. McCarthy, Royal Bank of Canada - VP, Associate General Counsel & Secretary [4]
------------------------------
Good morning. Today, we'll be voting by ballot except as otherwise advised by the Chair. Shareholders who haven't voted by proxy and proxyholders who are present received a ballot at the registration desk. Please print your name clearly and sign these ballots. Votes will be counted by the scrutineers. Preliminary results will be announced later this morning, and final results will be posted on our website. Only registered shareholders or their proxyholders are entitled to propose or second motions. A simple majority is required to approve matters voted on at this meeting.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [5]
------------------------------
Thank you, Karen. To facilitate proceedings, we've asked a select group of RBC employees, who are shareholders or proxyholders, to move and second motions. I'll call on them at the appropriate time.
Before moving to the first item of business, I'd like to take a moment today to remember our esteemed colleague, Rick George, who sadly passed away last August. Rick was an extraordinary member of our board and one of Canada's most highly regarded business leaders. We were very saddened by his passing, and he will be missed. On behalf of the bank, we once again extend our sincere condolences to Rick's family.
Going back now to the business of the meeting, I'll begin with the election of directors. Your board places strong emphasis upon the selection of director candidates, assessing the board's existing strengths against the evolving needs of RBC. An important element of this is ensuring that a diversity of viewpoints, backgrounds and experiences are present at the board. This year, the number of directors to be elected has been fixed by the board at 13. Biographies of each nominee begin on Page 10 of the circular.
One of the nominees is standing for election for the first time. Jeffery Yabuki is the President and CEO of Fiserv, a leading global provider of financial services technology solutions. Since his appointment as CEO at Fiserv in 2005, Jeff has reshaped the company, with a focus on the delivery of mission-critical technology solutions that enable its clients to deliver a differentiated financial services experience. We welcome the extensive expertise that Jeff brings to RBC, and we are very pleased to welcome to -- him to the board.
I'll now ask Karen to read the names of those proposed for election as directors, and I would ask each of them to stand and remain standing as their names are called.
------------------------------
Karen E. McCarthy, Royal Bank of Canada - VP, Associate General Counsel & Secretary [6]
------------------------------
The following individuals are proposed for election as directors: Andrew Chisholm, Jacynthe Côté, Toos Daruvala, David Denison, Alice Laberge, Michael McCain, David McKay, Heather Munroe-Blum, Thomas Renyi, Kathleen Taylor, Bridget van Kralingen, Thierry Vandal and Jeffery Yabuki.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [7]
------------------------------
Thank you, Karen. I'll now ask Rachel Megitt to nominate the directors.
------------------------------
Rachel Megitt, [8]
------------------------------
Rachel Megitt here. My name is Rachel Megitt. I have worked for RBC for 7 years, and I'm currently the Head of Business Transformation Canada in Capital Markets. I am pleased to nominate each of the persons named by the Secretary to be elected as a director of the bank, to hold office until the close of the next Annual Meeting of Common Shareholders or until their successors are either elected or appointed.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [9]
------------------------------
Thank you. Are there any questions or comments on the nominations? Again, seeing none, I'll declare the nominations closed, and we'll now proceed with the vote. On ballot A, please mark your vote on the election of directors.
(Voting)
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [10]
------------------------------
The next item on the agenda is the appointment of the auditor. I'll now ask Shekher Puri and Jason Ho to make a motion for the appointment of the auditor.
------------------------------
Shekher Puri, [11]
------------------------------
Madame Chair, my name is Shekher Puri. I've worked with RBC for 16 years, and I'm currently Senior Director of RBC Mutual Funds Distribution and Financial Planning, Personal & Commercial Banking. I move that PricewaterhouseCoopers be appointed auditor of the bank until the close of the next Annual Meeting of Common Shareholders.
------------------------------
Jason Ho, [12]
------------------------------
My name is Jason Ho. I have worked with RBC since last year, and I'm currently Director, Internal Audit Services - Enterprise Risk. I second the motion.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [13]
------------------------------
Thank you both. The motion has been moved and seconded. Is there any discussion?
We'll now proceed with the vote. Again, on ballot A, please mark your vote on the appointment of the auditor.
(Voting)
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [14]
------------------------------
The next item of business on the agenda is the shareholder advisory vote on our approach to executive compensation. The text of this advisory resolution is set out on Page 4 of the circular. We hope that you've had a chance to review our compensation discussion and analysis in this year's circular, which explains in detail how our compensation programs are designed to pay for performance and are aligned with effective risk management practices and the long-term interest of our shareholders. We take a progressive approach to continuously improving our compensation programs, integrating best practices and responding to input from our shareholders and our independent compensation adviser.
In considering our approach to compensation in the future, the board will take into account the results of today's vote, together with other feedback received from shareholders.
I'm going to now ask [Mark Baco] and [Nida Colloft] to make a motion to approve this resolution.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [15]
------------------------------
Madam Chair, my name is [Mark Baco]. I have work with RBC for over 17 years, and I'm currently Head of Portfolio Management at RBC Dominion Securities. I move, on an advisory basis and not to diminish the role and responsibilities of the Board of Directors, that the shareholders accept the approach to executive compensation disclosed in the management proxy circular delivered in advance of the Annual Meeting of Common Shareholders.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [16]
------------------------------
Madam Chair, my name is [Nida Colloft]. I have worked with RBC for over 7 years. I am a Director at the Chief Data Office in Technology and Operations. I second the motion.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [17]
------------------------------
Thank you very much. The motion has been moved and seconded. Is there any discussion on the motion? Microphone #4.
------------------------------
Willie Gagnon, [18]
------------------------------
(foreign language) Madam President, my name is Willie Gagnon. I act on account of MÃDAC, the Mouvement d'éducation et de défense des actionnaires. As each year, we intervene on these points, this policy adopted after proposal of the MÃDAC, let me remind the shareholders that following a MÃDAC proposal in 2009, we -- I used to and I will not speak for too long on the topic as I will be coming back to it based on a proposal to the bank. Each year, we calculate the equity ratio, which is a comparison of the highest-paid official of the bank and the median income. Last year, your ratio was 109. Last year -- in 2014, it was 109; 74 in 2015; 2016, 76. And this year, your ratio is 79. The bank has given us this ratio without wanting to publish it. We would have appreciated being able to know this ratio, have it published in your proxy. You know that this is now a common practice in the U.S. It is regulated. Obviously, we invite you -- let me say that your ratio is not the highest of the sector. There are some banks whose ratio is much higher than yours. But other financial institutions, such as Desjardins, have a much lower ratio, around 33, 30 to 33, whereas your equity ratio is 79 this year. For all these reasons, we invite all shareholders to vote against the resolution -- the motion.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [19]
------------------------------
Thank you very much, M. Gagnon. In terms of the comment on the executive pay ratio, thank you for being back again this year and bringing this to our attention. As I've said to shareholders before, and it's outlined in our proxy circular, we have a very detailed approach to reviewing and setting executive compensation at RBC. We take into account a number of benchmarks, including the executive pay ratio, the vertical ratio that M. Gagnon has mentioned. It is one of the factors that the board looks to. It is a narrow measure, one that's not easily comparable institution to institution, as you've just pointed out in your comments around Desjardins. And so I think at this point, the board will continue with its practice of considering that pay ratio as part of our deliberations, along with many, many, many other benchmarks as we continue to supervise and oversee executive comp at RBC. Thank you.
Again, microphone #4.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [20]
------------------------------
I'm [Nick Sars], and I'm a shareholder and a customer. And I oppose your approach to executive compensation, not because it's illogical, it seems to make sense. But when the outcome defies common sense, there must be something wrong. I ask you and your senior management, how big does your house have to be, how many luxury cars do you have to drive, how big must your portfolio be for you to feel fulfilled? And by my calculation, your CEO earned a little over $13 million last year. That's $139 a minute. Are you truly asking us to believe that he would be less fulfilled if he were paid half that or even 1/10 of that? If the leadership of the bank needs such a trivial point as to know whether they're doing a good job, they may not be the right people to lead this bank into the future. So as a shareholder and a customer, I am -- I value their dedication, their hard work, their creativity but not that much. So can you not find a better way to recognize and reward your loyal employees and leaders? And just a piece of perspective, if you take the nonexecutive officer compensation for the duration of the meeting, we're over $20,000 already. That's more than I can look forward from CPP.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [21]
------------------------------
Thank you very much for your comments today. I'll be brief in saying once again that the board takes this responsibility very seriously, spends a great deal of time on it, receives external advice as to its approach to this, does a great deal of benchmarking. And as we said in the circular, we are very comfortable that the approach we've taken with respect to Mr. McKay, who is an outstanding Chief Executive Officer of RBC, is the right one and in the best interest of the enterprise. But thank you for your point of view, and thank you for being with us today.
We'll now proceed with the vote. Again, on ballot A, please mark your vote on our approach to executive compensation.
(Voting)
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [22]
------------------------------
At this point in the meeting, I'm going to ask the scrutineers to collect ballot A. Please raise your hand so that the scrutineers can identify you if you're holding a ballot here in the room. We'll do it right now while we're collecting the ballots.
While we're collecting the ballots, I just wanted to let you know that we received a comment on the webcast that relates to this topic and I think best handled while we're on it. And the comment is, since management and directors are direct beneficiaries of the say-on-pay proposal, I suppose directors because they have set the compensation and, of course, executives because they are receiving it, it's the considerative opinion of this shareholder that they should not vote their shares on this issue. To vote on this issue perhaps in their view puts them in a conflict position. And so should those groups be asked to withhold, I think the -- to the extent the senior executives hold shares of the bank, it will be difficult to restrict shareholder rights. And when they act as proxyholders for other shareholders and directors, obviously, they're doing so to carry out the will of the broader shareholder group. That said, we'd like to thank you for bringing this topic up, and we'll take it into further consideration. Thank you.
Any more ballots? Looks like we have them all. The voting is now closed on all matters. While the scrutineers are tabulating the ballots, we're going to see a short video, celebrating a number of different ways that RBC helped clients thrive and communities prosper this past year.
(presentation)
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [23]
------------------------------
Very nice. At this point in the program, we're going to move to question period. I would like to remind you that questions should be of interest to all shareholders and not of a personal nature. If your question relates to a personal matter, please speak with the RBC representatives at our information desk in the lobby.
If you are a shareholder or a proxyholder and have a question, please proceed to the nearest microphone. Shareholders who are watching the annual meeting via the Internet may also submit questions through the website. Please give us your name and tell us whether you are a shareholder or a proxyholder.
And I'm now going to invite Dave McKay to lead the question period. Dave, once again, over to you.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [24]
------------------------------
Thank you, Katie, and I'm going to open the floor for questions. And it looks like they've lined up quickly at microphone 4. So please start.
==============================
Questions and Answers
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [1]
------------------------------
Mr. Chairman, my name is [Nico McNicol], and I'm a shareholder. And I want to congratulate the members of the -- your team for the outstanding job they have done for shareholders this year. And I'm also interested in your diversity and inclusion, which I don't really quite understand exactly how you're going to implement that. But I'm also -- you mentioned the Borealis AI and sort of like looking at artificial intelligence. And I am interested in just how that is going to fit into your program in the future.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [2]
------------------------------
Sure. So a couple of themes there. One, we fundamentally believe that diversity and inclusion is the foundation to innovation inside a company and inside a country, in a society. And therefore, to achieve the innovation, the ideas and the services that we want to bring to support our customers in the future really requires a diverse workforce, diversity across all dimensions. And therefore, that's the foundation of our diversity and inclusion. It's good for our country. It's good for innovation in our economy. It's good for RBC. And it's a very important part of our culture and our values. And we live it every day, and it's part of our leadership models I talked about in my speech. So that's how diversity and inclusion link to innovation. A big part of that innovation agenda is Borealis AI and using the capabilities in the artificial intelligence world to support not only our customers but our staff in delivering services to a customer, to bring ideas in real time, to connect with the customer, to be relevant to a customer. The world of AI and data, I think it allows us to be better for our customers, our employees to be better for our customers and our customers to self-serve in a world that's changing rapidly. So our team of scientists, many of them here in Toronto, a number, as I've said, across the country, in Edmonton, Waterloo, Montréal's a big AI center. This is a technology that I think is going to deliver exciting new services and make our lives easier to transact and to work in a world that's changing digitally. So we're very excited about Borealis AI and our leadership team there. And that's how those 2 worlds of diversity and inclusion link to innovation, link to AI. But the final thing I'll say is, at its core, a really important message is that we are still a client relationship bank first. And this technology tools, a digitally enabled relationship bank delivered through technology, putting people, customers at the center and our employees with our customers is the real message.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [3]
------------------------------
And the stress you're putting on the client, too.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [4]
------------------------------
Thank you for your question and your support.
Yes, microphone 4 again.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [5]
------------------------------
Mr. McKay, my name is [Linda Schwaye], I'm from Montréal, came in special for this meeting. Now through the -- last year, one of the major banks, not RBC, but they announced that they were outsourcing some jobs. And immediately, I became curious and interested in what was happening. And as these announcements go from a bank, they're usually preceded by the statement: We have a responsibility to our shareholders. And rightly so. However, when I heard that this bank was outsourcing some jobs, I really became quite annoyed because I didn't want them to do that, and I'm a shareholder. And so as a result of that, I sent to the 5 banks a proposal to be put in to vote that the practice of outsourcing should cease because I didn't think it was necessary anymore. And I thought it was disruptive to the families and employees involved. And as a shareholder, I didn't want this to be done in my name. And so, as I say, I sent this proposal to all the banks. Now in -- with -- I've had many conference calls with all of them, and I decided, I agreed to withdraw the proposal in return for a statement of their future policy regarding outsourcing. Now this morning, I noticed something very oblique in your statement, but I was wondering if you would just put a little -- expand a little more on RBC's policy regarding outsourcing.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [6]
------------------------------
Thank you for your question. And our commitment, as you heard in my speech to jobs in Canada, is paramount to us being a Canadian bank. We have 58,000 employees in Canada. And if you look over the last 5 to 10 years, despite all the technology changes that we constantly talk about, that number has grown by 5%. So we're creating new roles, we're creating new opportunities in Canada. The commitment we made is to only look at outsourcing in those situations where we don't have the capabilities in Canada, we can't find them, we don't have the skills in Canada, which is very different than our philosophy 10, 15 years ago, where we might have outsourced for other reasons, potentially cost competitiveness. So that's our commitment in our supplier code of conduct to really focus on outsourcing in Canada, but only seek those opportunities where -- and it's the right -- where we don't have the capability in Canada, we can't find it. Much of our outsourcing is in Canada. And I think outsourcing as a term is not a bad term, there's things that our organization is not as good at as another company is. It could be a big company like IBM, it could be a smaller company in our country. We always look for relative capability. And if someone can serve our -- help serve our clients better than we can, we should partner with them. And therefore, broadly, I wouldn't put a negative connotation to outsourcing. But certainly support your context of creating jobs in Canada and being very clear in the reasons, if and when we do, it has to be for a narrower set of reasons. And that's the commitment we made, and we've had that dialogue. So thank you for your question. Now hopefully, that clarifies and is consistent with your understanding of our policy to really focus on Canadian jobs.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [7]
------------------------------
Yes, no. I'm very glad to hear that it will -- there will be no outsourcing with regard to -- or concern about cost. That will not be one of the factors. Am I correct in saying that?
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [8]
------------------------------
That would be not the sole factor.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [9]
------------------------------
Not the sole factor. Well, okay. Well, except that, any time. And everybody heard this, so that's fine.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [10]
------------------------------
You have the record. Thank you for your question.
We have a question in microphone 5.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [11]
------------------------------
My name is [Leslie Davos], I'm a shareholder. My question is about 15 years ago or so, you were so hot about getting into the insurance business and expanding it and have insurance facilities in every branch in this country. Last year, you sold it. Can you explain that to me, why all of the sudden? I think the insurance business is a great business because if you lose monies this year, you jack up the prices next year and recoup what you lost and make more.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [12]
------------------------------
So you're saying not a very client-friendly business, is that what you're saying?
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [13]
------------------------------
Well -- and I'm an insurance broker, so I should know.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [14]
------------------------------
Well, thank you for that question. Yes, we did do a strategic review. And this is a process that we do every year. We think about all of our businesses in the context of a long-term customer franchise and in the context of the returns it could provide to the shareholder going forward. So we're always forward-looking on this. Not looking at the past, how it's performed, but necessarily, how will it continue to perform in the future. As we looked, and you're referring specifically to our property and casualty business, because we did maintain in our growing -- our life insurance business and creditor protection business, but this is specific to home and auto insurance. We made a strategic determination that the returns to shareholders and the invested capital that we had in that business was not going to meet our target thresholds to a profitability and return on investment. And we saw volatility in claims rates, we saw significant fraud in claim rate, we saw legislative action that created an instability in the marketplace, so it was hard for us to get comfortable that we could generate a fair return for shareholders. And therefore, as you'd expect a management team to do, we made the decision that we weren't the best owners of this franchise going forward. Despite it being an important customer service, we found an incredible partner in Aviva Financial, who is -- has the scale and has the technology capability to manufacture and underwrite this risk. And we will distribute their product through to our customers. So we're still in the business from the perspective of offering these services because property and casualty is a very important financial service to -- and a financial product to Canadians, as you know as a broker. We were not the best manufacturer and underwriter of that risk, and therefore, with Aviva and Royal, we have a broader product shelf. We limit our risk to distribution and we have a long term, a 15-year, agreement to distribute that product. We maintain that service to customers. And I think we found a much better place. And we've redeployed that capital into other business franchises. So I think that, hopefully, answers your question, but great question.
I'm going to go to 6. Please go to microphone if you have a question.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [15]
------------------------------
(inaudible)
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [16]
------------------------------
Oh, okay. Thank you for the question.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [17]
------------------------------
(inaudible)
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [18]
------------------------------
I hear you. I hear you.
Microphone 6, and then we'll go to 4.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [19]
------------------------------
Mr. McKay, I'm from [Paul Durnin] from Burlington. You have spoken only briefly about NAFTA, and in maybe the idea that there is some risk there. While I'm afraid that I'm a pessimist in this matter and I believe Washington will turn it down and that is what has been promised in previous election campaigns, as you recall. Now what -- how will the bank be affected directly if NAFTA has a very negative final outcome?
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [20]
------------------------------
Thank you for your question. First, I would say I'm more of an optimist that we will come to a successful resolution of NAFTA. We remain very close to all constituents and parties in this, from governments to businesses on both sides of the borders, as we have strong networks, not only in Canada, obviously, at the federal provincial level, but also at the state and federal level in the United States. When there's so much mutual benefit to maintaining this agreement, we are hopeful that all 3 parties come to an agreement at the end of the day. There are some very difficult changes that are being proposed that have to be resolved, from rules of origin, which we've made a lot of progress on; but also the sunset clauses on the agreement, how it's going to terminate; and the dispute mechanism clauses, are all very important to having a good agreement for Canada. And therefore, I think we know that the Canadian government's in Washington right now negotiating those key clauses. The agreement does need modernizing. Just if you look at the definition of what trade is in the auto sector, we don't count all the content that's digital content within the automobile. And therefore, as you look at what's going to -- automobile's going to be going forward, to not count that is really ignoring the value creation and the trade that's happening in rules of origin. So the agreement, in a number of areas, needs modernizing, and those discussions are ongoing. But I am hopeful that, given the mutual benefits and how difficult it would be if this was torn up and -- I think we're going to find an agreement. Having said that, if we don't, your question is what's the impact? Well, the strength of RBC is based on the strength of our economy and our clients. And therefore, you would expect that if customers didn't have -- commercial customers, corporates, didn't have access to the U.S. market or had a significant tariff, as we fall back, we expect, to WTO tariffs, that would impact our business. Having said that, if we look at the impact of falling back to WTO-based tariffs, our estimation is that it would only have roughly 0.1% effect on GDP. So the WTO tariff structure, assuming that's the foundation to elimination or disruption to NAFTA, provides a fair degree of understanding certainty of the cost of that cross-border tariff. So I think those are relative points to say there are other backups if NAFTA is disrupted. But again, commercial customers, if they lose their markets, will be challenged. Canadian jobs relying on that export will be challenged. It's difficult to say sector-by-sector, depending on how the tariffs are applied and whether we fall back to WTO. They're all great uncertainties. So we've done a number of scenario analysis within the organization to look at various scenarios, but it's hard to put probabilities on those scenarios. So we monitor that. Canadians, if you look at markets, are largely looking through this disruption right now and looking to a positive outcome. So I think those would be my perspectives right now.
We're going to go to microphone 4, and I think it's from Mr. -- MÃDAC. Mr. Gagnon?
------------------------------
Daniel Thouin, [21]
------------------------------
(foreign language) I'm Daniel Thouin, President of MÃDAC. Madam Chair, members of the board, in preparing my comment on proposal 1 that we made and then withdrew, this is on Page 105 of the circular. I would just like to say, in preparation, what we have done over the last few years. It's -- we have partnered with Canadian banks over 20 years to improve their managements and their activities in board organization. And let me mention a few good results that we are very proud of at MÃDAC. The distinction, first of all, are independence between Presidents of the Board and CEO of the company, the separation of roles, as I have just said; consultative voting, which is a result in 2009 following the financial crisis; voting also on -- of shareholders in terms of percentage as a way of checking whether percentage-held shareholders are in line with the votes of smaller shareholders; and a term limit of 12 years of directors in public companies; also the presence of women on boards of administration, this is one of our strong proposals over the last years which has given results, as we see today in Canada, with 3 women as the head of boards in the large banks. It's results that we can be very proud of. As a preamble to our proposal, like -- democratization of access to the board through making it easier for proxies to stand to director positions on the board, we submitted a proposal that will open up the way for more shareholders to be able to stand to -- as directors to public companies. This proposal was modeled on other proposals in Québec. The FTQ has 3 designated positions for people from the work organizations representing shareholders. You answered to this proposal that the bank already had a process that allows shareholders to stand for election at the board, that you have a specific policy set up in 2007. And so we considered that your policy was satisfying and we withdrew that proposal. Let me come to our second proposal now that will not be put to the vote either. You gave us a response, accepted to give us a response, which is published in the circular also. This is a commitment to decarbonization of our economy. You know, and all shareholders know, that the banks are really well positioned to change, in a sustainable way, the habits that we have developed over the last century or 2 to use and abuse fossil fuels. We are currently at a critical point where change must happen in an urgent manner. Banks have set up a Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosure, TCFD. And this task force includes representatives from RBC, Scotia, BMO, TD, and also the teacher's group and a Québec group also, and also the retirees of Ontario -- of the province's public workers. We asked for you to publish the results of the task force and respect their conclusions. In your response, you say that you have already participated since 2007 in a committee and another group -- on environmental issues. And so for these reasons, we accepted to withdraw our proposal. And we see here again that your response was quite satisfactory compared to that of other banks. We are very satisfied and we would like to recognize your leadership on that issue.
I will let my colleague speak to the other 2 proposals, Mr. Gagnon.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [22]
------------------------------
Thanks for your engagements throughout year and the dialogue and for your comments today.
------------------------------
Willie Gagnon, [23]
------------------------------
(foreign language) Mr. President, Willie Gagnon. I also act on behalf of MÃDAC. If I may add to my boss' intervention, M. Thouin, here at present, regarding the environment and decarbonization. You should know that yesterday, M. Louis Morisset declared we better understand now the state of communication on climate change in Canada. Now we will be hoping to improve communication on the risks and governance processes, taking into accounts the point of view of investors. This was a declaration made in the publication of a report on that topic. And we understand, reading this report, that new legislation will frame these issues. And we hope you will take all this into account, that you will consult the report and set up all necessary measures. I will now be speaking about the other 2 proposals that we sent to the bank. Let me mention that all proposals, the 4 proposals we sent to the Royal Bank this year were also sent to the other banks. And that we, in all cases, withdrew them from the vote. We think that the fact of having sent all proposals, same proposals, to the 5 banks was good for us. The following proposal reads as -- the proposal #3 reads as proposed. It is proposed that the certification of some business practices for the sale of financial products and services, it is proposed on the Board of Director require of its executive officers a written declaration on compliance with the principles of loyalty, integrity and honesty. You understand the principle, this came in after emails from the employees of the bank. We agreed to withdraw this proposal because the bank has taken measures to face this issue. We also saw that the bank participated in the investigation by the Canadian authority, the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, which investigated. And since we withdrew this proposal and the bank published its circular -- [let me wait]. Once again, the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, in March last year, published a report with 5 points. The culture of the banks is one that is at high risk. The compensation policies could increase the risk of financial risky sales. Some circuits are at higher risk. The governance framework does not allow a proper risk management linked to sales practices. And the policies deemed at risk mitigation are not sufficient. So this is not MÃDAC's position, but rather that of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada in its report. We have spoken to 2 other banks of -- with this issues, and they said that the Financial Consumer Agency did not have systemic issues in its report. Please let us know what you will do based on this report. Even if it is not a systemic problem, we want to know what the bank will do based on this report. Our last proposal had to do with the equity ratio, I will not come back to that, seeing as I already spoke about it at this mic this morning. Let me just say that in our discussions, which were good discussions with the bank, the question of the distortion per sector was raised. The question of this distortion of the equity ratio, based on the formula you used, depending whether you used as the mean, the median remuneration of bank employees or of the general population in Canada, you have different results. And also, you use different average incomes worldwide. This issue has been raised. Let me say that this is now the rule, it is the law in the U.S. for this ratio to be published. And you also do publish this in your circular, saying that in the absence of legislation in Canada, it would be risky to publish this equity ratio, in fact. Understood. But the underlying question is the legislation should be changed. This will no doubt be MÃDAC's next line of action, and we hope to have your support in our approach, obviously. Thank you for the quality of your responses. As M. Thouin said before me, not all banks answered in such a clear fashion to our questions. Look at their circulars to understand this.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [24]
------------------------------
(inaudible), thank you for ongoing dialogue over the year and your interest in making our society and our company better. I know there wasn't a question in there, but I do want to maybe say a few words about one of the subjects you talked about, and that's sales practices in Canada. We are very proud of our culture as a sales organization. I think we put -- I know we put the customer at the center of everything we do. Customer satisfaction, #1 in J.D. Power, is one of our key metrics, our internal customer sat metrics. So the customer comes first. Importantly, I think the primary conclusion from the FCAC result is that there is no systemic problems in sales practices in the country across the banks. That was the clear conclusion. To continue to mitigate against the risk of, there being, there are a number of recommendations that you highlighted that all banks should maintain good governance over. And we fully agree that this is an evolving world, we're constantly reevaluating our sales practices as the markets change, customer change, products change. But I can assure you, and the key results are there in our customer satisfaction numbers, we put the customer at the center of everything we do. The second thing I'll say is that compensation for sales of services and products, for the majority of our employees, is a very small part of their compensation. The majority of their compensation is salary. And therefore, we evaluate their performance at all times in conjunction with sales, but first with customer satisfaction in mind. And we're very proud of our sales culture in the organization. We maintain it, we nurture it, we focus on it from top to bottom. The board always asks about this from a governance perspective. Therefore -- but the primary conclusion we took from the FCAC result was that there is no systemic problem in the country. And therefore, these recommendations are to continue to reinforce that. But I thank you for your engagement and your dialogue over the past year and over the coming year. I'm sure we'll continue to have dialogue. We really appreciate your comments.
I'm going to -- if you'd like to come back up, I'm going to move to microphone 6. But then certainly would like to engage with you further. But I should give a chance for the gentleman at microphone 6. And M. Gagnon, I'll come back to 4 if you'd like to continue.
Yes?
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [25]
------------------------------
Mr. McKay, when you took City National, my understanding was that this was the bank of Hollywood movie stars. And you have sort of -- yes, it's private wealth management to a big degree and it has more cities than Los Angeles, it has major U.S. cities. Now the question I have is, when -- just how much retail service have they got for Canadian tourists in the U.S.? And I'm going to expand this, let's face it, the small U.S. banks don't want your Canadian money. They've got to get an agent just to get it back to Canada to get their U.S. out of it, and you've got fees for that. So let's just -- what kind of services, retail, are there in the U.S. for Canadian tourists that are as direct and convenient as possible? Okay, simplify...
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [26]
------------------------------
I got your question, yes. The focus of City National Bank is an entrepreneurial company serving entrepreneurs. And entertainment was a big part of the focus of the organization, City National, in the 50's, 60's, 70's. Still is a major part of the business, but only roughly 20% of City National's franchise. There are number of other sectors, from real estate to professional services, to technology, to quick service restaurants. There are a number of industries where City National focuses their commercial energy on serving customers. So a much more diversified company from a client perspective, from a product perspective and from geographic perspective, as you referenced, expanding out of the State of California into New York, into Nashville, into Nevada and other markets, now Boston, now Washington, as we talked about. So more expansive. But their focus is serving entrepreneurial customers in the United States. They are not focused per se on having a broad retail network. This is a commercial private bank focused on a small number of clients in a number of important markets. But not a broad retail bank. And particularly in those markets in Florida, where Canadians like to spend their winter, this is not a franchise that we bought to act -- to serve that marketplace. We do have an online bank that has been incredibly successful with roughly a little over 300,000, I think 350,000 Canadians. And this digital bank with almost no physical footprint has been really serving a large number of Canadian clients very, very well. There is no physical network to walk into, but this -- the design of this bank to move money across Canada, U.S. currencies, to pay bills, to access ATMs in the United States, has proven to be very successful and then it has high customer satisfaction numbers. So we've decided to serve Canadian snowbirds, as we call them, tourists, through this fashion rather than building a very expensive branch network. And customers have told us, for the most part, other than -- there are other customers like yourself who has said, "Boy, I wish I could have a branch in Naples, Florida. Boy, I wish you were in Palm Beach." When we looked at the cost/return to the shareholder and how many people we think would access that and we still come to the conclusion that I don't think the market's big enough for us to put that cost structure in at this point in time. We constantly reevaluate that. I was just in Palm Beach last week speaking to a whole group of snowbirds from the province of Québec. There are roughly 300, 400 there. And I do get that question, but I've had the same answer then, that we -- the feedback we're getting on our digital cross-border bank, it's so easy to use, so strong, best-in-class in the market. I think that's the strategy that we're going to continue with going forward. So unfortunately, I'm not going to have a network of branches for you to walk in, in the United States, but if you're in L.A., you're welcome to come to see City National. We'd love to see you there or in New York City. But we don't have any plans for an extensive network in the state of Florida and other markets where snowbirds go, in Nevada. So thank you for your question.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [27]
------------------------------
There is a retail service then in L.A. and Chicago for -- at City National?
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [28]
------------------------------
Certainly, those branches are available to support. If you're in that marketplace, you're welcome to come in to City National Bank. We do not have to connectivity to your Canadian accounts, and we don't have plans, because the focus of City National to convert that into a cross-border retail bank, City National is a very focused bank on high net worth commercial customers in those 5 segments. And their success has been because they're focused and disciplined and create real competitive advantage in the customers and the businesses they serve. I think the key to success in City National is to keeping them focused and not stretching them into something that is not part of their focus.
And we have any other questions? Four.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [29]
------------------------------
I'm still [Nick Sirus] and I'm still a shareholder and a customer. I'd like to commend Madam Chairperson on her significant holdings of stock in the bank. And I'd like to join her in welcoming Mr. Yabuki. And I'd like to particularly congratulate him on having made a significant investment in the shares of the bank. It puts him as one of the largest shareholders of the board in terms of the money they have put in from their own pocket. And I think that demonstrates alignment of the board with the shareholders. And I'm all for shareholder sweat equity, but I think putting some of your own money demonstrates a commitment that I would like to commend. So thank you, sir.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [30]
------------------------------
Thank you for your comment.
Mr. Gagnon?
------------------------------
Willie Gagnon, [31]
------------------------------
(foreign language) Here I am again. I'm still acting on behalf of MÃDAC. And I would like on the basis of, I guess, of the report that I mentioned earlier. And based on your response earlier, I had hoped or planned for you to tell me that the report said, indeed, that there were no systemic issues. This gives the impression that this is a scripted response by all banks. My question is the following. Based on this report, will you change anything in your sales practices or not? In other terms, does the report give any follow-up or not?
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [32]
------------------------------
Follow-up question, that the report is useful in highlighting areas that we need to continue to manage to make sure our practices don't slip. We are constantly changing our sales practice. They are not static, they are dynamic, as I mentioned. Customers change, products change, market opportunity changes. And therefore, to create an environment where our employees feel that they're treated fairly and there's opportunity, and to make sure that we don't create the environment where our employees feel pressured to offer service to a client, we're constantly reevaluating our services. We did our own internal study of our sales practices in Canada and the U.S. after the news of what happened at Wells Fargo. We didn't wait for the FCAC results. We conducted a very detailed third-party review of our sales practices. We looked at customer complaints, we looked at employee engagement. We have a policy, we want to hear from employees, we survey them all the time to hear how they're feeling about things. We take that and we make changes based on that. So we're always making changes to sales targets and sales practices and sales routines. It's part of why we're successful because we're adjusting to a world that's changing. So it's not static. And we're not disregarding the FCAC, I just don't want to everyone to have the impression that there was a major finding that these processes and recommendations are solving for. They are there to make sure we don't change and we don't fall into these bad practices. But the conclusion was clearly -- and you've read it, that there is not a systemic risk in Canada. But we don't want there to be a systemic risk and we have to stay on top of it. And we accept that and we are working with those recommendations actively. So hopefully, that is what you're hoping to hear.
Microphone 4.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [33]
------------------------------
Mr. President, I'd like to go back to last year. Last year, you gave out $150 to 150 young Canadians. And you saw -- we saw how they multiplied it. I have a granddaughter, I'm -- one of my grandchildren. I'm proud of them all. And last year, her school turtle teamed up with Sir John A. Macdonald on a walkathon to raise money for children to overcome cancer. By herself, she raised $2,000 towards that project. And last year after the meeting, I went to her and I said, "Kiddo, why don't you go to see your local Royal Bank manager, make an appointment and see if you can get $150." At 13 years of age, she is quite timid sometimes, and she didn't go to her Royal Bank branch. But that initiative of the bank last year inspired me to know that I'm dealing with the right bank since the age of 7. I'm now 85.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [34]
------------------------------
Thank you so much for that comment. I know you're really proud of your granddaughter. We are incredibly proud of our Canada 150 campaign, as we call it, and really inspiring youth to make a difference in our world through random acts of kindness. And the stories that we've gotten back from those youth across the country who've taken that $150, and just like your granddaughter did, multiplied it with other donations and really made a difference, the stories about the fabric of our country is incredibly heartwarming. And I think it's one of the great things that we've done. And I am very proud of the team. And I'm proud of our clients who approached us. And the e-mails I got and the letters I got from parents and grandparents like yourself, whose grandkids put on a suit and came in and talked to that branch manager and received that $150 with the only requirement that they tell us what they did with it and what difference they made, we're incredibly proud. And I know Mary DePaoli and the team designed this and implemented it. And thank you for mentioning that. I don't think we had it in the video, did we? We probably should have. But yes, thank you for that comment.
Do I have any other questions? I don't think so.
------------------------------
Unidentified Company Representative, [35]
------------------------------
Number one.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [36]
------------------------------
Sorry, number one down here, sorry. Yes?
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [37]
------------------------------
Good morning. My name is [Richard Sandbrook], I'm a customer and a shareholder. I'm not as long a shareholder or customer as the previous gentlemen. I'm very impressed. I did buy my first shares in Royal Bank about 30 years ago. I think they called that period Black Monday. And I think I paid all of $4 for my shares.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [38]
------------------------------
Good timing.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [39]
------------------------------
So you know what the dividends are. I don't think Warren Buffett is threatened, but I'm very impressed. Along with this year, obviously, a great year financially. But I'll, like the previous gentleman, I want to compliment the firm on the qualitative aspects of the investment, particularly, I guess, its continued focus on high ethical standards, risk management. It's one thing to achieve numbers but still do it in a risk-controlled, and that's really tough. Love the ROE. I know investors, we talk about it all the time, and it's like the green light. But I see divisions with different ROEs and I know it's important to keep diversified. You can't -- I've seen companies fail over that time because they thought they had, oh, this is the highest ROE and they just got too concentrated and forgot the balance and the mix. What I also liked in the qualitative side was the customer service levels are maintained and are huge. And in line with the previous gentlemen's comment, it's really this supporting community engagement, which, to me, also makes good sense. Healthy communities are a great place to do business with. And personally in particular this year, I have to compliment RBC's Winter Olympics support. I think we all became more engaged. And certainly, we saw that girls can indeed play a great game of hockey. I have a daughter.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [40]
------------------------------
And other sports.
------------------------------
Unidentified Shareholder, [41]
------------------------------
Anyways, my question is something you mentioned last year and I think you closed a bit, which is Future Launch, which is massive. As an investor, I guess I should be concerned that it's an investment, not an expense, so that there's a plan for how it helps. Obviously, it'll benefit a lot of people. Could you add a little more clarity to sort of what the program is, especially for millennials? Because I think they'd be highly interested, as well as the parents of millennials. So again, thanks for a great year.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [42]
------------------------------
Thank you for your incredibly summary of our investment thesis around volatility and ROE and premium growth. So you said it perfectly. So thank you. Absolutely, we believe that a strong Canada leads to a strong RBC. And we are going to celebrate our 150th anniversary next year in Halifax, which is we're incredibly excited about. And we plan to be here for another 150 years. I won't be here, but there will be these meetings, maybe digitally, and we'll be celebrating. Making sure our youth engage in the economy and are given opportunities to lead, we think, is incredibly important. And we're worried that the skill set shift is happening so fast that our youth are not being prepared for the future of work, to lead our economy and to contribute to our economy at an early age. And it's critical that we enable these youth to contribute and lead. And we feel very strongly that RBC has a role to play in making sure our communities prosper. It's very important in our business strategy to connect to youth. And the world is changing. I would say, when we asked youth 10, 20 years ago how did they connect to RBC, they said, "My parents brought me in when I was 6, to open my first account." That's how I started, that's how, I think, most people started. Increasingly, that's not the case anymore, that parents are embedding banking capabilities within other products that enable youth to transact, so it's so important that we connect to youth in different ways than we did before. But the primary objective is to make sure that youth are given the skills, the right education, to work with educators. I think we can get a better return on our tax dollars, our investment in education, if we focus on the right skills, if we have work-integrated learning opportunities, if we help the network to find the right jobs. And our program is also designed -- we fundamentally believe -- work-integrated learning opportunities, which is part of this, which is co-ops, internships, apprenticeships, it's a great democratizer, a great support of diversity and inclusion, that when you don't know someone in that company, that there is a job access through your school, through your high school, through your post-secondary education, to get into the job market, to get that experience that's so important. For me, I started as a computer programmer. It was really interesting. But after 8 months, I figured I'm not going to do this my whole career and I switched streams, I changed my academic focus. I could have done 4 years of education. Figured out, got a degree in computer science, worked for a couple of years and then gone back to school to change. At the beginning of second year, I switched my focus. Better return on my investment and time, much better return on the province of Ontario's investment, money and time. And therefore, that's what we're trying to achieve, is to make sure youth connect and understand it. And they're screaming for it. They just want to know where the opportunities lie, how should I apply myself? So what we think this is so important as a leading company in Canada to help make these connections. Last week, I just participated with John Stackhouse, who I work with in the office of the CEO, and a panel. And we brought panelists from the agriculture industry, from different technology industries. And they talked about how they are providing work-integrated learning opportunities and how work was changing and how important it was, early in our education process, to get these experiences. And after an hour of watching these amazing panelists, 3 different industries and companies, I said, "The best thing we can do is to send this 1-hour video to every high school in the country." And I guarantee you they will watch it because it gave a real insight. So that -- we see the need, we hear the need, we know we can make an impact. We know this is really, really important for our country. Want to have this dialogue with governments. And that's why it's important to Canada and it's important to RBC. So thank you for that question. You're going to get a good return of your investment.
Mr. Gagnon.
------------------------------
Willie Gagnon, [43]
------------------------------
(foreign language) Mr. President, It's me again, Willie Gagnon on behalf of the MÃDAC. And I promise you that this will be my last question, and it will be short. You will know that there's a debate in Québec right now on the closure of various branches of Desjardins in particular. We fully understand the reasons for these closures, banking is done more and more over the Internet now, and TD spoke about this at their General Assembly last year -- last week. And CIBC spoke about it yesterday also. The President told us that 2% of their branches had been closed last year. I'd like to know if you closed any branches this year. And if you did so, how many?
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [44]
------------------------------
Thank you, Mr. Gagnon, for your question. I'm going to ask Neil McLaughlin, our head of the Canadian retail bank, personal banking to take the microphone. Yes, we absolutely have closed branches. I think it's really important, as we watch and you referenced it in your question, how Canadians' financial service needs are changing and how they're using us is changing. Hopefully, you heard in my speech how mobile is our #1 channel now. Our strategy is to respond to changing customer needs and to allocate our capital and resources to meet those changing needs. And I think it's unquestionable in our society that those needs are changing. Our branch system is still a critical part of our delivery network. And I think the absolute number that Neil will quote, I think, is around 5%, Neil. But before I give out the data, why don't you, you have all the data. I'll ask Neil McLaughlin to continue to answer your question, but a very good question. Thank you.
------------------------------
Neil McLaughlin, Royal Bank of Canada - Group Head of Personal & Commercial Banking [45]
------------------------------
Thanks for the question. So just maybe to give you the exact number. We closed 43 branches last year. We also opened branches. And really, to Dave's point, it's about following our customers in terms of where do they want to access us and what are their behaviors. So a couple of things we'd point out. We do see trends, fewer and fewer customers are coming into branches, and that's been a trend for a while. And you referenced that in terms of technology through use of the phone that Dave mentioned. So that is something we think about, and it's in response to customers, as they're essentially requesting and we're delivering more and more access points. So if we rewind the clock, it was ATMs and then it was a contact center and then it was PC-based banking and now mobile banking. So there's more and more channels for our customers to access us and there are some places where we've decided to take out some physical capacity. A couple of things that I think we'd also like to point out, we do look at this in terms of the overall way we make our capabilities convenient for customers. So it is that collection of capability. And many of these places, we haven't had, up until this point, any staff that we've really had to part ways with. It's been over time and in a very slow process. So our approach to this is that we are following our customers. We are not trying to take our branch network and all the services it provides and force customers to a place and that en masse, we're seeing them really direct us what type of services do they want. So we can say we've been very, very vocal, our branches and our people, Dave talked about the importance of advisors and relationships and that we're digitally enabled, but we're a relationship bank. And we're very, very committed to that. And we been very upfront with our employees that the branch will play a critical role now, and for as far as we can plan, our branch network will be vital to our success and how we serve customers.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [46]
------------------------------
(foreign language) Mr. Gagnon, important question.
------------------------------
Willie Gagnon, [47]
------------------------------
(foreign language) If I understood correctly, 5%, 43 branches. Is that right -- branches, is that it?
------------------------------
Neil McLaughlin, Royal Bank of Canada - Group Head of Personal & Commercial Banking [48]
------------------------------
That would be below 5%.
------------------------------
David I. McKay, Royal Bank of Canada - President, CEO & Director [49]
------------------------------
Okay. Well, I think that brings -- I don't see anyone at any of the microphones. So thank you very much for your questions. I'll hand the meeting back to Katie.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [50]
------------------------------
Thank you, Dave. I'd just like to echo Dave's comments and thank all shareholders. We have one more question from the web that I'd like to address, it's for a shareholder who would love to see us bring the AGM to Ottawa in his lifetime.
I'm not sure what that time frame is, but just to say that we do, on occasion, as you've noticed, generally about every 3 years, we'll move the RBC meeting to another Canadian destination, location, where we have a chance to engage with local customers; with local staff and teams; and also, of course, with local investors. So that is in our regular cadence. And as a result of this comment, we will, for sure, take Ottawa into consideration for future years.
And I'd also just like to say thank you again to all shareholders for being with us today, for engaging so well. And in particular, M. Gagnon and M. Thouin and Ms. [Schwaye], who have been working with us, in the case of MÃDAC, for years; in the case of Ms. Schwaye , all through this year, a high level of engagement and one that we really appreciate and look forward to continuing in 2018.
I'm now going to call on Joe Chirico to report the preliminary voting results, which will also be posted on the screens. Final results will be posted on the bank's website and on SEDAR, Joe?
------------------------------
Joseph Chirico, [51]
------------------------------
For the information of shareholders, the scrutineers wish to report that 788,173,755 shares, or 54.58% of eligible shares, have been voted at this meeting.
The results for the election of directors are: A substantial majority of the votes cast at the meeting were voted in favor of each of the 13 nominees named in the Management Proxy Circular, with each nominee receiving an excess of 97.76% in favor.
The results for the appointment of auditor are: 99.84% voted in favor of PricewaterhouseCoopers, LLP, and 0.016% withheld from voting.
The results for the advisory vote on the approach to executive compensation, 95.55% voted in favor and 4.45% voted against.
------------------------------
Kathleen P. Taylor, Royal Bank of Canada - Chairman of the Board [52]
------------------------------
Thank you, Joe. I now declare that the 13 nominees named in the circular have been duly elected as directors, PricewaterhouseCoopers has been appointed as the auditor for the 2018 fiscal year, and the advisory vote on the bank's approach to executive compensation has been approved.
Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to thank you for participating in our meeting today. But just before we close, on behalf of the board and our shareholders, I would like to express our sincere appreciation to RBC employees everywhere, whose dedication and commitment to the success of our clients continues to be a true competitive advantage for the organization.
I'd also like to thank Dave McKay, not only for his continued strong leadership of RBC, but also for his values-led leadership, his focus on youth, his commitment to helping our clients thrive and our communities prosper. Thank you, Dave.
The meeting is now concluded. (foreign language) Thank you all for joining us today.
------------------------------
Definitions
------------------------------
PRELIMINARY TRANSCRIPT: "Preliminary Transcript" indicates that the
Transcript has been published in near real-time by an experienced
professional transcriber. While the Preliminary Transcript is highly
accurate, it has not been edited to ensure the entire transcription
represents a verbatim report of the call.
EDITED TRANSCRIPT: "Edited Transcript" indicates that a team of professional
editors have listened to the event a second time to confirm that the
content of the call has been transcribed accurately and in full.
------------------------------
Disclaimer
------------------------------
Thomson Reuters reserves the right to make changes to documents, content, or other
information on this web site without obligation to notify any person of
such changes.
In the conference calls upon which Event Transcripts are based, companies
may make projections or other forward-looking statements regarding a variety
of items. Such forward-looking statements are based upon current
expectations and involve risks and uncertainties. Actual results may differ
materially from those stated in any forward-looking statement based on a
number of important factors and risks, which are more specifically
identified in the companies' most recent SEC filings. Although the companies
may indicate and believe that the assumptions underlying the forward-looking
statements are reasonable, any of the assumptions could prove inaccurate or
incorrect and, therefore, there can be no assurance that the results
contemplated in the forward-looking statements will be realized.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN EVENT TRANSCRIPTS IS A TEXTUAL REPRESENTATION
OF THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S CONFERENCE CALL AND WHILE EFFORTS ARE MADE TO
PROVIDE AN ACCURATE TRANSCRIPTION, THERE MAY BE MATERIAL ERRORS, OMISSIONS,
OR INACCURACIES IN THE REPORTING OF THE SUBSTANCE OF THE CONFERENCE CALLS.
IN NO WAY DOES THOMSON REUTERS OR THE APPLICABLE COMPANY ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER
DECISIONS MADE BASED UPON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THIS WEB SITE OR IN
ANY EVENT TRANSCRIPT. USERS ARE ADVISED TO REVIEW THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S
CONFERENCE CALL ITSELF AND THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S SEC FILINGS BEFORE
MAKING ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS.
------------------------------
Copyright 2018 Thomson Reuters. All Rights Reserved.
------------------------------